Blog

How Metal Roofing Outperforms Asphalt Shingles in Every Way

Date Modified: May 22 2023

The picture shows the top of a building's metal roof, which offers many benefits for those looking for a long term solution.

If you're thinking about replacing your roof, you might be overwhelmed by the number of options available. From slate to wood to tile, there are many types of roofing materials to choose from. But two of the most common and popular choices are metal and asphalt shingles. How do they compare? Which one is better for your home?

In this article, we'll show you how metal roofing beats asphalt shingles in every aspect, from lifespan to durability to fire resistance. We'll also give you some tips on how to choose the right material for your roof and where to find the best metal roofing products and contractors.

When you're finished reading, you'll have a clear idea of why metal roofing is the superior choice over asphalt shingles and how you can benefit from installing a metal roof on your home.

Let's get started!

1. Lifespan: Metal Roofing Lasts Longer Than Asphalt Shingles

Blue metal roof on a house

One of the most important factors to consider when choosing a roofing material is how long it will last. After all, you don't want to spend money and time on a roof that will need to be replaced soon.

Metal roofing has a much longer lifespan than asphalt shingles. A typical metal roof can last up to 40 years or more, depending on the type and quality of the metal. Some metal roofs, such as zinc and copper, can even last up to 100 years!

Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, have a much shorter lifespan. The average asphalt shingle roof lasts between 12 and 20 years, depending on the climate and maintenance. Asphalt shingles tend to deteriorate faster in areas with extreme weather conditions, such as high heat, humidity, or hail.

Winner: Metal Roofing

2. Durability: Metal Roofing Can Withstand Any Weather Conditions

Green metal roof on a two story home.

Another factor to consider when choosing a roofing material is how well it can withstand different weather conditions. You want a top roofing contractor that can protect your home from rain, snow, wind, hail, and fire.

Metal roofing is one of the most durable roofing materials available. It can resist any type of weather condition without cracking, curling, or fading. Metal roofs are also resistant to corrosion, rust, mold, and insects.

Metal roofs are especially good for areas with heavy snowfall or hailstorms. The smooth and slippery surface of metal roofs allows snow and ice to slide off easily, preventing ice dams and leaks. Metal roofs are also able to reflect heat and sunlight, keeping your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter.

Asphalt shingles are not as durable as metal roofs. They are prone to damage from high winds, hail, and fire. Asphalt shingles can also absorb heat and moisture, causing them to warp, shrink, or rot over time. Asphalt shingles also require more maintenance than metal roofs, such as regular cleaning and sealing.

Winner: Metal Roofing

3. Fire Resistance: Metal Roofing Is Noncombustible And Safe

5V metal panel roofing

Fire resistance is another factor to consider when choosing a roofing material. You want a roof that can prevent or slow down the spread of fire in case of an emergency.

Metal roofing is noncombustible and safe. It has a Class A fire rating, which means it has the highest level of fire resistance among roofing materials. Metal roofs do not catch fire or melt when exposed to flames or sparks.

Asphalt shingles are combustible and risky. They have a Class C fire rating, which means they have the lowest level of fire resistance among roofing materials. Asphalt shingles can catch fire or melt when exposed to flames or sparks.

Winner: Metal Roofing

4. Maintenance: Metal Roofing Requires Less Care And Attention

Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Is Better? - corrugated-banner-main

Maintenance is another factor to consider when choosing a new roofing material. You want a roof that doesn't require too much care and attention.

Metal roofing requires less maintenance than asphalt shingles. Metal roofs are easy to clean and inspect from the ground level. You just need to clear the gutters and debris occasionally and check for any signs of damage or wear.

Asphalt shingles require more maintenance than metal roofs. Asphalt shingle roofs will need regular inspections and repairs from a professional contractor. You also need to replace any missing or damaged shingles as soon as possible to prevent leaks and further damage.

Winner: Metal Roofing

5. Installation Complexity: Metal Roofing Requires More Skill And Experience

a home made with metal roofing and siding

Installation complexity is another factor to consider when choosing a roofing material. You want a residential roofing top that can be installed quickly and efficiently by a qualified contractor.

Metal roofing requires more skill and experience than using asphalt roof shingles. Metal roof installation is a complicated process that involves precise measurements, cutting, bending, fastening, and sealing of metal panels. Metal roofs also need proper ventilation and insulation systems to prevent condensation and heat loss.

Asphalt shingles are easier to install than metal roofs. Asphalt shingle installation on an existing roof is a simple process that involves laying down rows of shingles on top of an underlayment layer and nailing them down securely.

Winner: Asphalt Shingles

6. Weight: Metal Roofing Is Lighter And Easier On Your Structure

pole barn built with metal roofing and siding systems

Weight is another factor to consider when choosing a roofing material. You want a roof that doesn't put too much stress on your structure.

Metal roofing is lighter than asphalt shingles. Metal roof replacement panels weigh between 50 and 150 pounds per 100 square feet (psf), depending on the type and thickness of the metal. This means they are easier on your structure and foundation.

Asphalt shingles are heavier than metal roofs. Asphalt shingles weigh between 200 and 400 psf (psf), depending on the type and quality of the asphalt. This means they can put more stress on your structure and foundation.

Winner: Metal Roofing

How To Choose The Right Material For Your Roof

Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt Shingles: Which Is Better? - PHOTO_C_-_TL200SL-DL_-_AdobeStock_144513116

As you can see, metal roofing outperforms asphalt shingles in every way except installation complexity. But how do you choose the right material for your roof?

The answer depends on your budget, preferences, and goals.

If you're looking for a low-cost option that can be installed quickly by any contractor, asphalt shingles might be a good choice for you.

However, if you're looking for a long-term investment that can save you money on energy bills, repairs, and replacements while enhancing the value and appearance of your home, metal roofing is definitely the way to go.

To get started with metal roofing, you need two things: high-quality metal panels and an experienced metal roofing contractor.

That's Where Mansea Metal Comes In!

At Mansea Metal, we produce exceptional metal panels for the following:

  • Roofing

  • Siding

  • Trim

  • Accessories

  • and more!

We use only premium-grade steel that's coated with Galvalume® for superior corrosion resistance. We also offer a variety of colors, styles, and finishes to suit any taste or design.

But we don't just sell metal panels. We also connect you with trusted contractors who can install them for you. Our network of professional installers has the skills, experience, and equipment to handle any metal roofing project, big or small.

So if you're ready to experience the benefits of metal roofing over asphalt shingles, contact us today. We'll help you find the best metal panels and contractors for your needs.

The Ultimate Guide to Metal Roofing

When it comes to roofing, durability and longevity are paramount, and there’s no better way to achieve both than with metal roofing. Whether you’re a homeowner looking to protect your investment or a business owner seeking a...

Frequently Asked Questions About Metal Roofing

Whether you’re installing a roof on a new home or are interested in upgrading your existing residential roof, selecting the right roofing material is an important decision. If you’re curious about metal roofing, the professionals at...

Can I Install a Skylight With a Metal Roof?

In areas like Kentucky, Illinois, and Ohio, severe weather conditions are all too common and can quickly take a toll on your roof. From excessive snowfall to high winds and tornados, your roof takes a beating. Thankfully, with innovative technology...

Spring Maintenance Tips to Protect Your Metal Roof

Original Blog Published April 24, 2019 This year, the Midwest, Central, and Eastern states experienced a more mild winter. States in these regions received heavier rainfall and below-average snowfall throughout the months of December to February....

Can You Install Metal Roofs in Winter?

Undoubtedly, the busiest time of year for roofing contractors is the spring and the fall. Most homeowners want to replace or fix their roofs during seasons with mild weather.However, most homeowners pursuing new roofing projects are under the...

Top 5 Fall Tips to Keep Up Your Metal Roof

Original Blog Published in 2019 Fall is in full effect and keeping your metal roof protected before winter hits is crucial. A metal roof is one of the longest lasting roofing materials you can purchase and install for your home or barn, but...

The (Metal) Roofs, Roofs, Roofs They’re On Fire!

Original article written 8/21/15 Metal Roofing As a top metal roof manufacturer, we are pretty biased when it comes to choosing metal panels over traditional asphalt shingles. We believe they are the right choice for every homeowner....

Seasonality and The Metal Process

Original article published 9/23/15 We receive many questions regarding the best time of year to buy metal building materials. As one of the top metal roofing, metal siding, and post frame building kits in Kentucky, fall is our busiest time of...

Reasons to Add Square Footage to Your Metal Pole Barn

Over the past few years, house prices in the US and in the world have been skyrocketing. In 2021, the sales price of new properties reached an all-time high of over $443,000. Because of the transformation of the American real estate market, adding...

Top Benefits of Having Gutters on a Pole Barn

The finishing touches can be the difference between something that lasts and something that gets worn out quickly.  Pole Barns make for great homes, workspaces, horse-homes, equipment storage areas, and more. Here at Mansea Metal, we...

The History of Post-Frame Buildings

Originally posted on 04/27/2016 Could you single-handedly construct a building in a month? We bet you could! That was the mindset at the creation of the post-frame building.  Post-frame buildings have a long history that...

Post-Frame Buildings vs. Steel Frame Buildings

Originally posted on 02/28/2017 In your pole barn building material search, you may have seen many different methods of construction, notably, post-frame and steel frame, but what is right for you? The obvious difference...

Top Benefits of Metal Buildings for RV Storage

Are you an RV enthusiast struggling to find the perfect storage solution for your recreational vehicle? Look no further! Mansea Metal brings you cutting-edge RV storage solutions through state-of-the-art metal buildings installation. Our...

Top 3 Heating Systems to Consider for Your Pole Barn

The more comfortable a space is, the more likely you are to use it. Some people use their pole barn for storage of materials. Much like a garage, this would not need to be a heated area. However, if you are like most pole barn owners, your...

Flooring and Ground Options for Your Pole Barn

Have farm equipment? How about a workshop on your property? Or maybe you have an RV or recreational vehicle you need to store? All of these needs and more can be satisfied with a pole barn. Owners of pole barns, or Midwestern Buildings as we...

Welcome to Our New Website!

We've added great new features and updated our content to bring you the most up to date information about our company.  Check back often for updates.

10 Year Anniversary & Customer Appreciation Event

In thinking about our 10 year anniversary, this moment of reflection, it is important to me. I believe it’s not the journey that matters - it’s who you take the journey with. And I am so proud of what this team has accomplished...

NASCAR Xfinity Alsco 300 Race Recap

Mansea Metal was honored to be a part of NASCAR this season. As proud partners of Dale Earnhardt Jrs racing team, JR Motorsports, Mansea showed their full support by attending the race with most of their work team in tow - some of which were...

NASCAR Ticket Giveaway

As stated in a previous post - Mansea Metal & Midwestern Buildings have teamed up with JR Motorsports, owned by Dale Earnhardt Jr., for the upcoming NASCAR Xfinity Series event. The Alsco 300 is to take place July 7th at Kentucky Speedway....

Memorial Day Special! - Premium Rib $1.85/LNFT

Premium Rib, Premium Pricing! Now through Memorial Day, our premium rib metal is discounted to $1.85 a linear foot. This is the perfect time to order metal for your roofing, siding, or pole barn project! As our most popular panel, Premium Rib...

Bet on MWB for Your Equine Pole Barns

The Kentucky Derby is quickly approaching - one of the most exciting times for horse enthusiasts! As a Kentucky rooted company, we know a thing or two about horses and how to create the perfect equestrian post-frame building. We not only focus...

Spring Post-Frame Building Specials

Spring into action and start building your dream with help from Mid Western Buildings! This spring we are offering greater affordability on our high-quality metal pole barn kits. Now through June 1st, we are offering not one, but TWO building...

Mansea Metal Unveils Renovated Office

This winter we got to work on a long-overdue front office remodel. As a metal and post-frame building supplier for commercial, residential, and agricultural customers, we wanted an updated space where all of our customers could come to feel welcomed...

Metal Roof Before & After

Before: After:   This Louisville, Kentucky home got a much-needed roofing makeover that significantly improves curb appeal. Manufactured on site, our red standing seam metal paneling updates the look of this home while also...

A Metal Workshop / Home Combo

With two metal manufacturing plants, Mansea Metal & Mid Western Buildings has provided high-quality, low-cost metal solutions for thousands of customers over the span of a decade. Throughout the years we have had the opportunity to help...

Santa Visits Mansea Metal

Santa and his elf, Connor, stopped by Mansea Metal this past Saturday to provide a little Christmas cheer to some lucky children!  Children from the Winchester, Kentucky area were able to meet Santa on Saturday, December 10, courtesy of...

Mansea Metal Illinois Announces Grand Opening Event

Mansea Metal, Illinois’ own metal roofing, siding, and post frame building manufacturer, will hosts it’s grand opening celebrating celebration Friday, August 19. A little over a year in the marking, the grand opening will be held at...

Mansea Metal Announces New Metal Panel Color

With 20 metal panel color choices, customers have limitless metal roofing and metal post frame building design options. To further create a more comprehensive list of color choices, Mansea Metal has added a new color to the mix: Fern Green. We...

Mansea Metal & Midwestern Buildings Featured on Wlex

Mansea Metal & Midwestern Buildings were recently featured on a special WLEX segment with Lee Cruse. In the 3 minute segment John Griffith, owner, discusses the benefits of metal panel roofing and metal pole barn packages. Watch below!...

Mansea Metal Releases Creative Radio Ads

Building materials are a hard sell on radio, especially metal panels, as people do not get a visual. One way we have found to stand out is to create creative radio ads that will catch listener's attention and draw them to our website. This...

#Manseamonday & #Postframefriday April Review

METAL ROOFING FEATURES: Colors: Our metal is available in 20 vibrant colors, granting you endless design options. Better yet, we use a Valspar WeatherXL paint system that limits fading and chalking! Crinkle Finish: Speaking of...

Don’t Be Lax, Get Your Metal Roofing Tax (Credit)

Improve your home with a metal roof and simultaneously improve your wallet! Thanks to the Energy Efficiency tax credit (and the energy efficient nature of metal roofing), if you install a metal roof on your home by December you qualify for a tax...

Mansea Metal Awarded Top 5 Honors

MANSEA METAL AWARDED TOP 5 HONORS AT THE ANNUAL WINCHESTER SCARECROW FESTIVAL Winchester, Ky. – Mansea Metal got into the fall season by participating in the 10th annual Winchester Scarecrow Festival. Located at Beech Spring Farms, the...

Mansea Metal Opens New Plant in Illinois

Winchester, Ky. - Mansea Metal will be opening the doors of its second location in Mt. Zion, Ill. in April 2015. “Mt. Zion is the perfect location for us to open our second branch. With its healthy farming community and its ideal location...

The Mansea Metal Difference

We Are The Manufacturer

Most of the companies who advertise metal roofing and siding or post-frame buildings are simply reselling products produced by someone else. We produce our own products from rolled steel and have large indoor yards that keep our lumber protected. That way, we control the quality and time of delivery to you. And that creates jobs right here in your home town.

Higher Quality Steel with Superior Finishes

The truth is not all steel is alike, especially when it comes to finishes. That’s why we use Sherwin-Williams WeatherXL™ Coil Coatings. Created to withstand most anything that comes its way, designed to maintain extreme resistance to abrasion, chipping and marring with tremendous color and gloss retention. And you get to select your favorites from more than 22 striking color options

You Won’t Be Shorted On Lumber

When we price a building package, we give you everything you need to ensure structural integrity. Like longer gable posts that extend to the top of the truss, not just tying in at the bottom. And long-lasting pressure-treated wood measuring .60 CCA. You won’t get this quality at a ‘big box’ store. Plus, we use 6x6’s along with 2x10’s and 2x12’s that are #1 grade.

Request a
FREE Quote
* Indicates required questions
Name *
First
Last
Email *
Phone #
Zip Code *
How can we help you?
You Won’t Find a Better Product, Value, or Service than with Mansea Metal Residential or Commercial. Pick-Up or Delivery.
217-350-0181
859-309-6394
859-544-2935
937-669-7893
937-502-3848